Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum. ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
STDs (Expert Forum)
conflicting IGG test results
Answered by
University of Washington
Seattle - WA
This forum is for questions and support regarding STD issues such as: Chlamydia, Crabs (pubic lice scabies), Gonorrhea, Hepatitis (viral), Herpes, HPV, Molluscum Contagiosum, PID, Rectal Infections, Syphilis, Trichomoniasis, Warts, Yeast Infection.All questions will be answered by H. Hunter Handsfield, M.D. or Edward W Hook, MD.
 |
conflicting IGG test results
by medques, Jul 18, 2007 12:00AM
All 4 herpes tests that I refer to are the IGG Herpes Select Quest Diag. that diff. b/t type 1 & 2. 1st test on 5/19/06. Result:Type 1 pos (4.93)& Type 2 neg (0.05).My b.f is only partner since neg test. We have had unprot'd sex since 12/06.Neither have had any symptoms,except what I think was a yeast infection in 01/07.Treated with dyflucan 2 x's.It went away in a couple of days each time,then came back in 2 wks. No culture taken.Seemed like yeast: white cottage cheese like discharge and all the other symptoms of a yeast infection. In 02/07 she prescribed 7 day yeast infection cream injections.It never came back.On 06/03/07,my b.f had an abrasion his penis after we had had alot of vigorous sex.Same night I noticed an abrasion on the inside lip of my vagina and both disappeared w/in a 2-3 days. During a regular physical, I told a NP about this & she ordered the same test as above on 6/6/07.No culture taken b.c abrasion was gone. Result:Type 1 pos (4.88) & Type 2 (1.50). She told me that I was pos for genital herpes. I had the same test thru Advanced Testing on 06/13/07.Results:Type 1 pos (>5) & Type 2 pos (2.64).My gyno and did the same test on 07/03/07.Result: Type 1 pos (>5)& Type 2 equivocal (1.05).
1. Is 1.50 a pos result?What do the conflicting test results mean?Is it possible that I don't have type 2? Could the 1.05 equivocal result be a false one since I appear to have 2 positive tests?Should I have another test?
1. Is 1.50 a pos result?What do the conflicting test results mean?Is it possible that I don't have type 2? Could the 1.05 equivocal result be a false one since I appear to have 2 positive tests?Should I have another test?
Doctor's Answer
by H. Hunter Handsfield, M.D., Jul 18, 2007 12:00AM
, Jul 18, 2007 12:00AM
In people with positive HSV-1 results, like you, mid-level HSV-2 results often are falsely positive. That is, when the HSV-2 ELISA ratio is positive above 1.0 but below 3.5, there is about a 50% chance each that the person does or does not have HSV-2.
Since you haven't had clear clinical evidence of genital herpes--I agree the symptoms you describe don't necessarily mean herpes in either you or your boyfriend--most likely you don't have HSV-2. However, it simply isn't possible to know for certain based on the currently available information. There are 3 approaches to sorting it out:
1) Your bf could have a blood test. Assuming he is your only partner over the past year, he would have to be the source of any HSV-2 infection (because your result was definitely negative last May). So if his test is negative for HSV-2, that would effectively rule it out for you. If positive, it would likely mean that you are infected as well.
2) You can have repeat HSV-2 testing by an entirely different method, such as the Kalon test (available in the UK, not yet widely available in the US); the BiokitUSA test, which is available; or a Western blot test, the gold standard. WB is available only at the University of Washington in Seattle, but your local lab will know how to refer a specimen for testing. The main drawback of WB is that it is expensive (I think around $150, plus whatever handling fees come from your doc's office or the local lab) and might not be covered by insurance.
3) You can wait for new abrasion-like symptoms or other symptoms of herpes and see your NP or other provider immediately, within 1-2 days of onset, for a culture or PCR test for HSV-2.
These three approaches are not mutually exclusive. If the cost isn't too big a deal for you, I suggest your bf get tested and you have blood sent for Western blot.
Good luck-- HHH, MD
Since you haven't had clear clinical evidence of genital herpes--I agree the symptoms you describe don't necessarily mean herpes in either you or your boyfriend--most likely you don't have HSV-2. However, it simply isn't possible to know for certain based on the currently available information. There are 3 approaches to sorting it out:
1) Your bf could have a blood test. Assuming he is your only partner over the past year, he would have to be the source of any HSV-2 infection (because your result was definitely negative last May). So if his test is negative for HSV-2, that would effectively rule it out for you. If positive, it would likely mean that you are infected as well.
2) You can have repeat HSV-2 testing by an entirely different method, such as the Kalon test (available in the UK, not yet widely available in the US); the BiokitUSA test, which is available; or a Western blot test, the gold standard. WB is available only at the University of Washington in Seattle, but your local lab will know how to refer a specimen for testing. The main drawback of WB is that it is expensive (I think around $150, plus whatever handling fees come from your doc's office or the local lab) and might not be covered by insurance.
3) You can wait for new abrasion-like symptoms or other symptoms of herpes and see your NP or other provider immediately, within 1-2 days of onset, for a culture or PCR test for HSV-2.
These three approaches are not mutually exclusive. If the cost isn't too big a deal for you, I suggest your bf get tested and you have blood sent for Western blot.
Good luck-- HHH, MD
Communities
Ask a Doctor Forums
Tools and Applications
Personal Information
Medical Information
Doctors and Partners
grace